The CIP is comprised of thirteen (13) members representing a diverse cross section of the citizens of Miami. The Mayor and City Commission appoint twelve of the thirteen Panel members with a single appointment by the Chief of Police.

The enabling ordinance requires that, with the exception of the appointment by the Chief of Police, members shall be either permanent residents of, or own real property in the City of Miami, or work or maintain a business in the City of Miami and have a good reputation for integrity and community service. Members shall not be current employees of the City of Miami or have a record of a felony conviction.